ITEC 325 2012spring ibarland

home—lects—exams—hws
D2L—breeze (snow day)

project-team-feedback
itec325 project feedback

Name                                                                                                     

Team Number                    Your role/responsibility                                                                                                     

Evaluation of other teams

Go to the other teams's websites, and actually try out each of their products. Leave feedback/thoughts/impressions on D2L, for each of those teams. Your feedback can include encouragement, constructive criticism, any bug-reports noticed while trying the site, and/or a wish-list of future features you'd like to see.
Your comments will not affect the grade of the other teams, but part of your grade is based on giving some thought-out feedback.

Note that you are allowed to try to enter “bad” inputs — either into the form, or POST/GET requests. However, do not attempt to inject SQL which alters (much less drops) any tables; you certainly can try to enter information which yields error messages, ill-formatted HTML pages, or even “bad” rows being stored in the table. Likewise, do not use tools/attacks that do more than make POST/GET requests. Keep in mind, other students may be trying such values on your forms — use htmlspecialchars, mysql_real_escape_string, and stripslashes (with get_magic_quotes_gpc()) as appropriate.

Imagine that you have six dear relatives, each starting a business in our class's project areas (what a coincidence!). For a gift, you will invest in each of the other teams' products. Make your judgement based on the product as presented and as you have tried it on-line, plus (say) 10hrs of touch-up work.

Fortunately you just won $12,000 in the lottery², and you'll allocate that among your six investments. (One possible allocation: $3000 to three teams, and $1000 to the other three.) (Don't enter any an amount next to your own project — you've already invested enough in your own project!)

•                      Team 1 (Team ARAS)
•                      Team 2 (Team Gold)
•                      Team 3 (The Smaech's)
•                      Team 4 (anonymous)
•                      Team 5 (Team Nameless)
•                      Team 6 (Halo)
•                      Team 7 (anonymous2)

Evaluation of your team

Consider your teammates in light of the following categories:

• Communication/Professionalism: Did they reply to emails/texts in a timely manner; available for meetings and on-time for them? If they had delays or difficulties, did they communicate this to the team?
• Completion: Did they do the work they were expected to? Did they put in sufficient time?
• Helpfulness: Did they contribute the team overall (ideas as well as code)? Were they approachable? Were they willing to help, when issues arose? Was working with them enjoyable?

• Teammate's name                                                            
  
  Teammate's role/responsibility                                                                                                                                                                
  
  Communication/Professionalism:                  Completion:                  Helpfulness:                 
  
  Any other comments about this teammate:
  
  
  
  
  
  I'll include the gist of this comment in summarized, unnattributed feedback to that person, unless you check here:         
• Teammate's name                                                            
  
  Teammate's role/responsibility                                                                                                                                                                
  
  Communication/Professionalism:                  Completion:                  Helpfulness:                 
  
  Any other comments about this teammate:
  
  
  
  
  
  I'll include the gist of this comment in summarized, unnattributed feedback to that person, unless you check here:         
• Teammate's name                                                            
  
  Teammate's role/responsibility                                                                                                                                                                
  
  Communication/Professionalism:                  Completion:                  Helpfulness:                 
  
  Any other comments about this teammate:
  
  
  
  
  
  I'll include the gist of this comment in summarized, unnattributed feedback to that person, unless you check here:         

Reflection on your project

What was your favorite part of your team's project?
(Is there a feature, idea, or bit of code that you are particularly proud of, personally?)





What would you do differently, if you had it to do over?





What tips/suggestions would you give next year's project teams?

home—lects—exams—hws
D2L—breeze (snow day)

©2012, Ian Barland, Radford University Last modified 2012.Apr.27 (Fri)

Please mail any suggestions (incl. typos, broken links) to ibarlandradford.edu